as an oilers fan – absolutely 100% without a doubt yes
callisterart
I absolutely loved Tuch but the Eichel trade was arguably one of the best trades in NHL history.
UnhealthyCheesecake
I think peak Matthews beats peak Eichel. It’s hard to compare with someone who almost potted 70 goals.
However, peak Matthews is behind him. He’s still a really good player, but he’s not the 60 goal guy anymore. Whether that’s cuz of injuries or what not, that can be up for debate.
Right now it is Eichel > Matthews
bigsmoke1420
Matthews is finding form
Madacon
Injuries suck, would’ve loved to see matthews healthy his whole career. Could’ve been something incredible.
jghtb
Yeah keep telling yourselves that lol
VGK9Logan
I dont keep up with the leafs so im bias, but some of the defensive plays ive seen eichel make make me put him over matthews. But again, I am bias
7 Comments
as an oilers fan – absolutely 100% without a doubt yes
I absolutely loved Tuch but the Eichel trade was arguably one of the best trades in NHL history.
I think peak Matthews beats peak Eichel. It’s hard to compare with someone who almost potted 70 goals.
However, peak Matthews is behind him. He’s still a really good player, but he’s not the 60 goal guy anymore. Whether that’s cuz of injuries or what not, that can be up for debate.
Right now it is Eichel > Matthews
Matthews is finding form
Injuries suck, would’ve loved to see matthews healthy his whole career. Could’ve been something incredible.
Yeah keep telling yourselves that lol
I dont keep up with the leafs so im bias, but some of the defensive plays ive seen eichel make make me put him over matthews. But again, I am bias