Désolé pour le retard sur celui-ci, je travaillais aujourd’hui et j’avais oublié. Mais je ne pense pas qu’il y aura beaucoup de débats sur ce sujet.
—
Beta1224
@Flames de Calgary
Désolé pour le retard sur celui-ci, je travaillais aujourd’hui et j’avais oublié. Mais je ne pense pas qu’il y aura beaucoup de débats sur ce sujet.
—
Beta1224
26 Comments
Giordano
Al MacInnis
Al MacInnes is the only acceptable answer here
AM2
Big Al.
pachal
MacInnis wins this one but HM to Giordano (yeah I think he was better than Suter).
Robyn Regher
Mike Stone how is this even a question
Al MacInnis with honourable mentions for Gio and Regehr…
How did baertschi not win this one
If Pekka Rautakallio had stuck around longer…
It’s regehr. Macinnis was sick. You don’t get points for being the best shut down guy in the nhl for a decade
#2
I can’t wait till the best goalie one tomorrow!
How can you leave out Paul Reinhart, Jamie Macoun and T. J. Brodie? 😠
Gotta be Al MacInnis, although I feel Tanev’s defense never was appreciated, Hanafin was able to be an amazing scoring blueliner cause Tanev could hold the D zone down by himself.
Hmmm, now I’m thinking repeats should have been allowed. Al MacInnis deserves this, but also Best Shot. Someone lesser will take one of those two categories due to no repeats.
So if I have to vote, Giordano, so Al can have Best Shot
Best defender or best defensemen? Very different answers.
Dougie Hamilton
Calgary has had a lot of great defencemen: MacInnes, Suter, Giordano. But the best defender of all time for the Flames is Brad McCrimmon. Top 10 plus/minus rating all time in the NHL. Without him, Calgary doesn’t win the Cup in 89. RIP to one of the greatest defencemen of all time.
Phil Housley
Chris Tanev
Macinnis, with a huge honourable mention to Giordano
Has to be McCrimmon or MacInnis
Regehr just plain mean