You can’t be the greatest if your name isn’t on the cup. Everyone on that list has at least one and most have multiple cups.
cam_huskers
They haven’t won shit.
Bootlegger1929
Should they be on the list though? Didn’t everyone else on there win one or more cups together?
SteakMan43
It’s because they haven’t won a cup, if they do, they will be up there
ckncardnblue
Brett Hull and Adam Oates
chemicool
Hull and Oates? They made some beautiful music together.
georgecostanza37
I will say i don’t think crosby-malkin belong at 3, but gretzky -kurri could also be in here to go along with gretzky-messier. Or gretzky-coffey if it’s just good players on the same team. McDavid and Draisaitl are awesome, but this list is literally like the mount rushmore of hockey. Let’s maybe revisit this in 10 years if they win a cup or two?
Jolly-Inflation5781
Who would you take off the list then?
BootNoodle
Sedin – Sedin
I’m obviously biased, but if we’re strictly talking duos…
-HumphreyBoggart-
Kane and Toews?
MRR19898
This might be the most homer take of all summer…
they haven’t even made a cup final yet lol
micropterus_dolomieu
They’ve played together 8 years, and haven’t even won the Western Conference Final yet. Give it a minute, eh?
Langwaa12
Like the list, order is fuked up though.
NinJ4ng
its honestly a crime to consider a duo top 10 all time never having won their own conference
its honestly a crime to respond to every instance of this argument with: “they will win next year i have a crystal ball”.
Medschoolmonkee
McDavid Drai will be up there too
BM19921992
Good list. Kane and Toews deserve to be on it before mcdavid and drai. They have how many cups and trophies together?..
Pip_n_Piper
Stevens-Niedermayer, maybe?
CountBeetlejuice
Ovi and Backstrom should be on this list, especially given Ovi is breaking all of Wayne’s records
Reallyme77
Ok so who are you taking out?
DangerRanger_21
If you want McDrai on the list you need the Sedins on there first
albertogonzalex
I can’t put my finger on exactly what that duo is missing compared to this list…
EndFinal8647
I like the four wings up there.
PreciousRoy78
Nah… Oiler fans’ right to be outraged got used up by the Seth Rohrbaugh being a douchebag troll to satiate the Yinzers. This list is fine
LT568690
Mario / Jagr is wayyyy too low at 6. They are 3rd or 4th. Top 2 are spot on
Separate_Flamingo_93
Gretzky and Messier rarely were on the ice at the same
olgartheviking
The most iconic Montreal duo is Bouillon-Dandenault. Change my mind.
TrickBoyDickBoy
Not nearly enough time. What McDavid & Drai have done for 2-3 years these duos did for a decade in their time.
xmaven10x
They don’t make that list ever without cups
GingySpice1998
What have they done?
To counter your point, I believe Toews and Kane should be there
red400404
I’m an oiler fan and I HOPE that in ten years, this is an argument. Today, they are still behind Kane and Toews.
yoosername456
They need at least 2 cups to make this list
Petit_Hughie
Crosby and Malkin before Richard and Béliveau?
Also, there’s some absolutely **TERRIBLE** takes here holy f*ck. Like the one in the title lol.
SweedishFish93
No Canadians should be on the list. They have been trash for years.
Zealousideal_Sky4614
Not it’s not when all the rest on the list are champions
JustWannaChill82
Shows how good Crosby n Malkin are. There on that list with some all time greats
Swiink
Sedins???
AnonThrowaway998877
Datsyuk-Zetterberg should be on there, but they probably just didn’t want to fill half the list with Red Wings.
37 Comments
You can’t be the greatest if your name isn’t on the cup. Everyone on that list has at least one and most have multiple cups.
They haven’t won shit.
Should they be on the list though? Didn’t everyone else on there win one or more cups together?
It’s because they haven’t won a cup, if they do, they will be up there
Brett Hull and Adam Oates
Hull and Oates? They made some beautiful music together.
I will say i don’t think crosby-malkin belong at 3, but gretzky -kurri could also be in here to go along with gretzky-messier. Or gretzky-coffey if it’s just good players on the same team. McDavid and Draisaitl are awesome, but this list is literally like the mount rushmore of hockey. Let’s maybe revisit this in 10 years if they win a cup or two?
Who would you take off the list then?
Sedin – Sedin
I’m obviously biased, but if we’re strictly talking duos…
Kane and Toews?
This might be the most homer take of all summer…
they haven’t even made a cup final yet lol
They’ve played together 8 years, and haven’t even won the Western Conference Final yet. Give it a minute, eh?
Like the list, order is fuked up though.
its honestly a crime to consider a duo top 10 all time never having won their own conference
its honestly a crime to respond to every instance of this argument with: “they will win next year i have a crystal ball”.
McDavid Drai will be up there too
Good list. Kane and Toews deserve to be on it before mcdavid and drai. They have how many cups and trophies together?..
Stevens-Niedermayer, maybe?
Ovi and Backstrom should be on this list, especially given Ovi is breaking all of Wayne’s records
Ok so who are you taking out?
If you want McDrai on the list you need the Sedins on there first
I can’t put my finger on exactly what that duo is missing compared to this list…
I like the four wings up there.
Nah… Oiler fans’ right to be outraged got used up by the Seth Rohrbaugh being a douchebag troll to satiate the Yinzers. This list is fine
Mario / Jagr is wayyyy too low at 6. They are 3rd or 4th. Top 2 are spot on
Gretzky and Messier rarely were on the ice at the same
The most iconic Montreal duo is Bouillon-Dandenault. Change my mind.
Not nearly enough time. What McDavid & Drai have done for 2-3 years these duos did for a decade in their time.
They don’t make that list ever without cups
What have they done?
To counter your point, I believe Toews and Kane should be there
I’m an oiler fan and I HOPE that in ten years, this is an argument. Today, they are still behind Kane and Toews.
They need at least 2 cups to make this list
Crosby and Malkin before Richard and Béliveau?
Also, there’s some absolutely **TERRIBLE** takes here holy f*ck. Like the one in the title lol.
No Canadians should be on the list. They have been trash for years.
Not it’s not when all the rest on the list are champions
Shows how good Crosby n Malkin are. There on that list with some all time greats
Sedins???
Datsyuk-Zetterberg should be on there, but they probably just didn’t want to fill half the list with Red Wings.