Maintenant que nous avons dépassé le repêchage et l’agence libre, il est temps de passer à l’annuelle /r/DetroitRedWings Fil de discussion sur le classement des espoirs ! Quant à la manière dont vous votez, c’est entièrement à vous de décider : certains peuvent accorder la plus grande importance au plafond ou à la hausse, d’autres peuvent accorder une plus grande importance à la préparation à la LNH – il n’y a pas de mauvaise réponse sur la façon de voter.
Un nouveau sondage sera publié tous les 2-3 jours en fonction de la proximité du vote jusqu’à ce que nous ayons terminé avec les 15 meilleurs prospects. J’inclurai 10~ prospects à chaque sondage et j’ajouterai un nouveau prospect après chaque sondage, alors discutez-en dans les commentaires et celui qui sera le plus mentionné sera ajouté ensuite.
Consultez les classements précédents du subreddit ici (à partir de 2018 !) : LIEN ICI
REMARQUES:
– Les critères de prospection seront définis à l’aide de Lignes directrices de la LNH.
– Après les classements de la saison dernière, un sondage a été réalisé pour déterminer s’il fallait ou non afficher les résultats du sondage. Continuer à masquer les résultats entre les sondages a donné lieu à plus de votes.
#1. Nate Danielson (C – 2023 #9) – 61% des 731 votes [Results]
#2. Axel Sandin-Pellikka (RD – 2023 #17) – 58% des 658 voix [Results]
#3. Sebastian Cossa (G – 2021 #15) – 52% des 635 votes [Results]
#4. Marco Kasper (C – 2022 #8) – 65% des 589 votes [Results]
#5. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard (AD – 2024 #15) – 59% des 455 voix [Results]
#6. Trey Augustine (G – 2023 #41) – 57% des 481 votes [Results]
—
SimplySolace
13 Comments
I’m going Mazur here. I think he’s got a little higher of a ceiling than Johansson (relative to where they COULD play in the lineup) and he’s also decently close to the NHL after a strong playoffs with GR.
Glad that Trey got the previous slot. Deserved. He should move higher once more guys listed above him graduate.
Buchelnikov has my vote until he gets seeded.
The top 6 matches my top 6 list, so I can’t complain there.
I think we’re entering a new tier of players here where certainty is a bit more important compared to overall upside. There’s some boom/bust guys still remaining like Buch/Soderblom/Buium/Wallinder. But overall Mazur/Johansson and even maybe Tuomisto seem more likely to provide an NHL impact right now.
AlJo, Mazur, Buch those are probably my next 3
Mazur gang rise up
I’m going Mazur, then Johansson. Hard to put anyone above AJ at this point, he will actually play NHL games this season.
Has Wallinder not been good? Seems like people were high on him at first, now it seems like I never see him mentioned as one of our better prospects.
There’s a noticeable drop after Augustine, and I think the next 5 in no particular order are Mazur, Wallinder, Buchelnikov, Al Johansson, and Buium
Personally I like Mazur
Having scouted Finnish prospects for years, I know a lot about Tuomisto and what he could bring to Detroit, and I would say he is either the seventh or eighth best prospect. Mazur is probably seventh given how much he has improved, but Antti makes the top ten for sure as a great offensive defenseman that can lead through PP / PK minutes, as well as a decent slapshot and wrist shot from the point.
I’m interested where people are on Jesse Kiiskinen. I think he’s on the fringe of cracking this top 15 list… u/SimplySolace, could you add him to the poll options next?
AlJo! Love Mazur, but AlJo could be an elite OD. And he’s ready now for his shot. He gets the nod as he’s further ahead. Love Botha ceiling
Mazur is the most NHL ready at this point, but I’m going with Buchelnikov because I think he has a higher ceiling.