Johnny Gaudreau a été élu Meilleurs Poignées ! Quel est le pire gardien de but des Flames ? Aucune réponse répétée, le commentaire le plus voté gagne
—
Beta1224
@Flames de Calgary
Johnny Gaudreau a été élu Meilleurs Poignées ! Quel est le pire gardien de but des Flames ? Aucune réponse répétée, le commentaire le plus voté gagne
—
Beta1224
43 Comments
I haven’t put in any names for this grid yet, but I am a certified Brian Elliott hater and he was just god awful when he was with us and is my pick for this
Edit: Brian Elliott was a huge reason why we got swept by the Ducks in 2017
I nominate myself, because if i was a goalie and played a game for the flames i wouldn’t stop a single puck
Recent memory tells me that Mike Smith was either absolutely dialled, or there wasn’t a chance in hell he was stopping a puck.
Kari Ramo had nights like that as well
Eddie lack?
Tyrone garner. I think he may have played a period,maybe two, but the man tried to play a puck shot wide from centre ice
Karri ramo lol
Grant Fuhr or Joni Ortio
Trevor Kidd. First round pick that everyone believed would be great
Eddie Lack for sure.
Roman Turek for being an absolute disappointment.
The worst goalie to play for the Flames was Grant Fuhr. In backing up Freddy Brathwaite, he was more than a full point of GAA higher and had an .856 save percentage to Freddy’s .905
Jason Muzzatti
Eddie Lack
Tank Commander Jonas Hiller
Grant Fuhr
One season in the twilight of his career. Former All Star. Went 5-13-2. Looks bizarre in a Flames uniform. Played behind a pretty bad team though.
Mike Smith. The terrible giveaways, the arm flailing, the blaming the other players, his attitude with the Oilers.
By the numbers it was Eddie Lack
By pure form 22-23 Markstrom was a historically massive fall from grace.
But spiritually (even if he never actually played for the Flames) the only answer is Tyler Parsons
Brent Krahn – Drafted ***9th overall*** in the 2000 NHL Draft and never played an NHL game for the Flames. Though he did get 1 game with the Stars and made 3 saves on 6 shots…
Mike Smith for his on ice performance and his media statements after becoming an Oiler.
Can I say 2022-2023 Jakob Markstrom but only on the first shot? If not then Brian Elliot
Lack
Trevor Kidd was taken over Martin Brodeur.
Leland Irving
Elliot
Leland Irving
Brian Elliott. One of the most disappointing trade losses.
I’m gonna give it to Wolf and Vladar after they try to backstop this sorry looking team this year
Eddie was Lacking in net
I’ve never been so pissed off at a Flames goalie than Brian Elliott. He was the reason we got swept in 2017.
Also the Blues drafted Jordan Kyrou with the pick we gave them.
Mike smith
He wasn’t bad on paper compared to some second string goalies. But he gave away so many pucks trying to play it behind the net, and he always choked when it really mattered. From a first string goalie that’s brutal.
Sadly, it’s Grant Fuhr. I love him in St.Louis as a kid. But he was so bad as a Flame.
How in the hell do you pick just one?!
Ken Wregget, JS Giguere, Jeff Reese, Andrei Trefilov, Rick Tabbaraci, they all sucked and the list just keeps going
Hiller
Most potential is Brett Hull no question.
Most underrated was Martin St.Louis.
Most wasted: Brett Hull
Best hands: Kent Nelson
Jon Gillies
Kris Russell. The only goalie that refused to wear pads.
Grant Fuhr
Roman Turek…after he signed a new contract
Jonas Hiller
Trevor Kidd
How is theo fleury not on this list?
Brent Krahn and Leland Irving
Can I just throw a vote for Tyler Parsons for getting my hopes up?