Hi there! It looks like you’ve posted an image. If this image is from an article, please provide a source. If it’s a meme, please ignore this comment. Thanks!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Habs) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Yea i dont see how anyone else makes an argument over him
mulder00
Agreed
farmsfarts
Kinda like Schaeffer for Calder, just give them the damn trophies now.
ddddeadhead1979
The way it has been given in the last 20 years he totally should win but I think they should give
It to guys like Carbo, Lethinen, Draper like they used to.
LukeBenny
I hate hockey trophies’ names. I never know what they’re for
Particular-Boot-4528
When will the award winners be announced?
toaster-struble
If Cirelli wins the Selke then Slavin or Seider should win the Norris. Is it the award for the best defensive forward at all costs? Or the best 2-way forward? Which would value offense.
Similarly, in regards to the Norris, is it the award for the best defender? Aka the best defensemen at playing DEFENSE or the best player at the defensemen position? Aka if you were creating a team and had first pick who would you take? Hands down a Makar, Werenski, Hughes etc over a pure shut down defender with little offense like a Slavin.
Make it make sense. The award definitions are either nuanced or we’re just not happy with the results (and rightfully so). Imo there should be a Bobby Orr trophy for the Bouchard, Eriksson types and a best Defender award for actual defensemen and not for forwards playing defense.
ChickenWinggggsss
Jesus christ it’s not even close holy
jimmym007
That’s fan votes, no? If so it’s irrelevant. Not saying he won’t win it but how fan votes do not reflect how media/gm (or whoever votes on the winner) is going to vote, especially with the team having the by far the biggest fan base
i-want-to-be-good
I’d like to see him win, but basing anything on a fan vote is pointless, especially the way we Habs fans like to stuff the ballot.
nscodeboy
In what world is Marner considered a candidate for the selke? I like him as a player , but defense is not his forte
MaxTheShape
Just imagine getting Hischier this summer and having 2 top 10 selke candidates as a 1-2 punch.
Sashaband
I kinda think that he is. There’s nobody even close…..this is literally a lock.
16 Comments
Hi there! It looks like you’ve posted an image. If this image is from an article, please provide a source. If it’s a meme, please ignore this comment. Thanks!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Habs) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[https://x.com/JFreshHockey/status/2045531308781130218/photo/1](https://x.com/JFreshHockey/status/2045531308781130218/photo/1)
I mean, he kind of is
Yea i dont see how anyone else makes an argument over him
Agreed
Kinda like Schaeffer for Calder, just give them the damn trophies now.
The way it has been given in the last 20 years he totally should win but I think they should give
It to guys like Carbo, Lethinen, Draper like they used to.
I hate hockey trophies’ names. I never know what they’re for
When will the award winners be announced?
If Cirelli wins the Selke then Slavin or Seider should win the Norris. Is it the award for the best defensive forward at all costs? Or the best 2-way forward? Which would value offense.
Similarly, in regards to the Norris, is it the award for the best defender? Aka the best defensemen at playing DEFENSE or the best player at the defensemen position? Aka if you were creating a team and had first pick who would you take? Hands down a Makar, Werenski, Hughes etc over a pure shut down defender with little offense like a Slavin.
Make it make sense. The award definitions are either nuanced or we’re just not happy with the results (and rightfully so). Imo there should be a Bobby Orr trophy for the Bouchard, Eriksson types and a best Defender award for actual defensemen and not for forwards playing defense.
Jesus christ it’s not even close holy
That’s fan votes, no? If so it’s irrelevant. Not saying he won’t win it but how fan votes do not reflect how media/gm (or whoever votes on the winner) is going to vote, especially with the team having the by far the biggest fan base
I’d like to see him win, but basing anything on a fan vote is pointless, especially the way we Habs fans like to stuff the ballot.
In what world is Marner considered a candidate for the selke? I like him as a player , but defense is not his forte
Just imagine getting Hischier this summer and having 2 top 10 selke candidates as a 1-2 punch.
I kinda think that he is. There’s nobody even close…..this is literally a lock.